The controversy surrounding talk show host Steve McKinney took another turn Thursday when Mr. McKinney broke his silence on the matter, saying he was better off financially during the Ingraham years than under the Christie government.
Mr. McKinney also defended his company, The Facilitators Five Star International PR Ltd., and explained the various government contracts it holds.
He said his company did more PR work with the Bahamas government during the Ingraham years – 1992 to 2002 – than under the Christie Administration.
Taking off on some of what was revealed by Prime Minister Hubert Ingraham at a press conference a day earlier, he said the company has a $45,000 per year legal contract through Bahamas Information Services to provide radio and television programmes on behalf of the Government of The Bahamas.
“Many local PR firms and agencies also have public relations contracts with the Government of the Bahamas,” Mr. McKinney said in a statement. “This is only right and fair.”
With regards his company’s contract for public relations services to the Ministry of Education, Mr. McKinney said the contract is for $45,000, and is also governed by the laws of The Bahamas.
“These are the only two contracts between myself, my firm and the Government of The Bahamas,” he said.
The controversy erupted Saturday night when Prime Minister Ingraham suggested during an FNM victory rally at Clifford Park that Mr. McKinney and radio talk show host Phillippa Russell would have to find their own ZNS.
In his statement, Mr. McKinney said that with regards the ZNS talk show contract, this is a one-year agreement that came about last year after Darold Miller left ZNS and a new host was needed for “Immediate Response”.
Mr. McKinney said after the board of the Broadcasting Corporation of The Bahamas approached him for a second time, he decided to assist – after initially being reluctant – and agreed to host the show from August 2006 to August 2007 for a talent fee of $200 per show.
“That is what Mr. Miller received,” he said. “That is all ZNS was offering and it is all I received - $100 per hour for two hours a day, five days a week.”
Mr. McKinney said the talent fees he received are earned through the sponsorship of the show.
“No commercials, no pay,” he said. “In fact, no ads, no show. I do not receive a salary from the public purse of ZNS. I receive a talent fee for providing my talent to the show. No more, no less.”
Although there has been uproar from some members of the public that the new prime minister is seeking to victimize Mr. McKinney, it was not an issue Mr. McKinney addressed in his press statement.
Mr. McKinney also did not address critics who have said that as a talk show host he was overly biased in favour of the former administration.
On Wednesday, Mr. Ingraham flatly denied that the two talk show hosts had been fired, insisting that ZNS talk shows have only been suspended “up to now.”
“I believe that the Bahamian people would want to be aware of the circumstances surrounding the employment of the two political personalities referred to by me at my party’s May 5 victory rally,” Mr. Ingraham said.
“And I believe the Bahamian tax payers would have an interest in knowing and have a right to know how the Progressive Liberal Party engaged the full machinery of the government and the resources of the Public Treasury specifically to orchestrate a campaign of distrust and resentment against me and my party.”
Mr. Ingraham said it was “interesting” that Mr. McKinney has three current contracts with the Government of The Bahamas.
He said the first is a three-year, $45,000 a year public relations contract signed with the Ministry of Education in November 2005; the second is another $45,000 a year public relations contract signed with the Ministry of Tourism last April, which includes speechwriting duties and an additional 15 percent gratuity at the conclusion of the contract.
The third was signed in July 2006 with the Broadcasting Corporation of The Bahamas for Mr. McKinney to serve as host of the “Immediate Response” talk show, for which he was paid $200 per show.
As for Ms. Russell, Mr. Ingraham tabled a contract that shows she was hired by BCB to host “Drive Time Talk” at a rate of $100 per show, or $26,000 per year.
“Both contracts concluded between the two political operatives and the Broadcasting Corporation of The Bahamas contained provisions for termination should the conduct of the individuals ‘reflect unfavorably on the reputation of the Corporation or discredit in any way its image,’” Mr. Ingraham said.
“While radio hosts are always entitled to their personal, political or other opinions, when engaged at the expense of the public purse, they must demonstrate a clear commitment to ensuring that all points of view are heard and respected on air,” the prime minister said. “The inability of these persons to provide unbiased commentary is self-evident.”
“[Opposition Leader Perry] Christie can kick and scream as much as he likes about victimization,” Mr. Ingraham continued. “We will victimize no one. At the same time we will not allow ZNS, which is maintained by taxpayers’ money, to be abused as a vulgar propaganda tool for one political party.”
He reiterated that each contract – each one signed by all parties – contains provisions as to how it may be terminated, but that no one has been terminated.
“Mr. McKinney still has $90,000 worth of contracts that are operational, up to now,” he said.
On Thursday, Mr. Christie released another statement on the matter in response to Prime Minister Ingraham. He accused the prime minister of trying to change the subject.
“He knows full well that what is at issue is his blatant victimization of Steve McKinney and Phillippa Russell for espousing political opinions that he has a difficulty with. The punitive action that has already been taken against Mr. McKinney – whether it is suspension or termination really does not matter – shows that Mr. Ingraham has already made good on his public threat to remove Mr. McKinney from the airwaves, as indeed he has done with Ms. Russell as well,” Mr. Christie said.
“This is a flagrant breach of the right to free expression guaranteed by our constitution. It is also a classic example of discrimination based on political opinions, which is also outlawed by our constitution. Even more fundamentally, Mr. Ingraham’s conduct in this matter has no place in a civilized society. It is, I repeat, political thuggery of the worst kind.”
Mr. Christie said Mr. Ingraham can throw up as many smokescreens as he likes.
“He can talk all he likes about which contracts Mr. McKinney may have with different government departments or corporations. That is simply Mr. Ingraham’s way of trying to divert the attention of the Bahamian people from the fact that he has been caught out – and caught out very badly – just days into his new administration,” he said.
Mr. Christie and the PLP called upon Mr. Ingraham to rescind the “punitive action” that he has taken against Mr. McKinney and Mrs. Russell.
“We further call upon him to publicly withdraw the threat of victimization that he publicly made against these individuals on Clifford Park,” the former prime minister said.
“We further call upon Mr. Ingraham to desist from victimizing anyone for holding or espousing political opinions he doesn’t like. Surely it is not asking too much for the prime minister to simply obey the constitution and deport himself according to law, and respect the rights and freedoms of others.”
By Candia Dames
The Bahama Journal